It’s time to admit something’s wrong with Tina

Embattled election conspiracy theorist Mesa County Clerk Tina Peters grins proudly for her mug shot taken upon her arrest on 2/10/2022

Lots of people have been saying it under their breath, but no one has come out and said it publicly. Mostly people have just gotten angry at Mesa County Clerk Tina Peters for her increasingly strange behavior, but maybe it’s time to start pitying Tina.

We can all agree that Tina’s behavior has been very far outside what is considered normal for an elected county clerk:

Normal clerks don’t compromise their own election equipment. They don’t flee the state on private jets, spend weeks hiding in safe houses in secret locations around the country or accept largesse from multi-millionaires to promote wacky election conspiracy theories. Normal clerks don’t blow off their obligation as clerks (pdf) to get certified to run elections as the state requires. Normal clerks don’t proclaim that the candidates who won an election shouldn’t have won because they were the wrong people to win. Normal county clerks don’t get their homes raided by the FBI. They don’t violate court rules, lie to judges, get arrested for obstruction, kick at law enforcement officers, grin in their mug shots, claim the deep state is out to get them and then blame the whole mess they’re in on U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland. Normal county clerks don’t serve as guest speakers before extremist groups and then applaud a call for their political opponent to be hanged and burned. Normal county clerks don’t go on the national talk show circuit and claim the Secretary of State is out to get them because they “won’t shut up.” Normal county clerks don’t get targeted with lawsuits and ethics complaints or get slapped with legal decrees blocking them from running elections, and normal clerks don’t start criminal defense funds.

And any county clerk who had engaged in such bizarre behavior would probably hold off on announcing a run for re-election, let alone just weeks later announce a run for statewide office instead.

Let’s face it. There is clearly something really wrong here, and it has nothing to do with George Soros, Merrick Garland, Jena Griswold, Mesa County District Attorney Dan Rubenstein, the deep state or Democrats, as Tina alleges.

It has everything to do with Tina Peters’ deteriorating mental state.

She has had a lot of stress lately

Why has Tina Peters has engaged in such increasingly over-the-top behavior? As an elected County Clerk still pulling down a gross salary of almost $93,000 a year (pdf) plus $28,000+ in benefits, we have a right to speculate.

Here’s my guess:

First, remember that Tina was completely unprepared for the office to which she was elected.

She had absolutely no experience working in a county clerk’s office when she ran for Clerk in 2018. The stress of having to get up to speed on all the functions, operations, and systems of the Clerk’s office, and managing personnel matters, would have been extreme. She also had to read and quickly memorize all of the laws, rules and regulations that dictate how her office operates, a task that likewise could have been overwhelming for someone without any prior experience. These complex tasks for someone unaccustomed to complexity could have generated prolonged anxiety as she struggled to figure it all out.

Add to this that Tina’s son was killed in a freak parachuting accident in 2017 while entertaining crowds at an airshow in New Jersey, no doubt an extraordinarily traumatic event that took a serious toll on her emotionally, and which clearly continues to exact a toll. She brings her son’s death up at almost all of her public talks, reinforcing that it’s clearly still a powerful factor in her emotional life.

Then she endured the public disgrace of the 574 forgotten ballots from the 2019 election that were discovered left in a ballot box in 2020, followed by a bipartisan recall effort in 2020, all of which must have been extremely stressful, even though the recall effort failed.

Photo: Tina Peters as a villain in the Marvel Avengers storyline Thanos.[Thanks to a reader for the correction. ] (ColoradoPols via Twitter)

Then after the November, 2020 election, many of the Mesa County residents who swallowed Trump’s big Lie about winning the election formed pressure groups like “Stand for The Constitution” and “Mesa County Concerned Citizen” and started to push their mass delusions about the election onto Tina in an attempt to turn her into their champion.

It worked.

In her public talks, Tina invariably talks about how many Mesa County citizens pressured her into pursuing what they believed to be “election irregularities.” Tina could have felt a strong need to appease these people to keep them liking her at a time when more and more people were starting to strongly disapprove of her, even if it meant she’d have to flush any remaining shred of credibility she may have had down the toilet.

She appears to have done just that, to the extent that she has even adopted their bizarre extremist beliefs. She has become one of them, to assure they will continue to approve of her.

Then in 2021, Tina’s husband divorced her.

The loss of a marriage and a child could easily push someone over the edge into debilitating depression and grief, and drive them toward something that draws them some kind of comforting approval. Add all the other stressors, and it may have all just been too much for Tina emotionally.

Where are the people who care about Tina’s mental state?

We aren’t psychologists, but everyone in Mesa County has had a front row seat to Tina’s increasingly fraught behavior for two years now, and we’ve seen it just get crazier and crazier. There’s been something else new and wild about Tina happening almost every day. One person joked he was going to start a new TV station, “KTNA — All Tina All the Time.”

We’ve earned the right to speculate on what is going on with her, since the answers don’t seem forthcoming from anywhere else.

Tina’s worsening behavior could indicate shades of many possible disorders, chief among them martyr complex, a victim mentality, narcissistic personality disorder, delusions of grandiosity, paranoia, borderline personality disorder, depression, disordered thinking, debilitating anxiety, grief, scapegoating, and more.

What’s really sad to see is how many people are willing to exploit Tina’s shaky mental state for their own gain: egging her on, idolizing her, applauding her, putting her on talk shows on the internet and on TV, giving her money and reinforcing her increasingly strange and senseless behavior to help advance their own extreme political agendas, with no serious consideration of the high personal cost of all of this to Tina herself.

Where are the people who are close to Tina, who see the changes going on in her and how they are destroying her? Where are Tina’s sane and trusted friends and family? Where are the people who really care for her, who are her guard rails, the people who love her and see her getting herself into deeper and deeper trouble? Where are the people who can get through to her, whose job it is to gently make her aware her behavior is way out of bounds and who will encourage her to get help?

They seem nowhere to be found.

And so Tina continues to be the laughing stock of the country, making people slack-jawed at the kookiness coming out of Colorado, like they’re watching some kind of freak show.

The point is, the time has come where have to finally admit what has become painfully obvious: Tina Peters’ mental state is fraught. She’s not well, we can all see it, and unfortunately there’s little anyone can do about it except Tina herself.

We can only hope that Tina will stop for a moment, contemplate the totality of her circumstances, and realize all the trouble, the problems, lawsuits, fines, legal expenses and possibly prison time she may be facing now because of her behavior. Let’s hope she somehow finds a way to get a grip on herself and sees fit to resign as Clerk, to take some of the pressure off. Barring that, people who fancy themselves her friends, including the Mesa County Republican Party — if they really are in fact true friends — should start urging Tina to spend some of her generous, taxpayer-funded salary on a thorough mental health evaluation by a competent professional so she can figure out what in the heck is happening to her and start getting the help she so desperately needs.

  18 comments for “It’s time to admit something’s wrong with Tina

    • Do they share/use those four-legged panties that republican women love to put on after church, after jesus goes to sleep?

  1. It is truly hard to watch Tina Peter’s strange behavior continue and not react with some compassion. Some physical or mental deterioration seems to be going on, whatever the cause. I do not condone her behavior in any way, but I do feel sorry for her.

  2. It is surprising that Mesa County Republicans don’t understand how much she’s dragging them down. Just like the Colorado 3rd, where over a month ago state senator Don Coram announced that he’s running against a similarly over-the-top and nutso Boebert, Republicans there have decided to stop the bleeding.

    On the other hand, the longer Peters continues in denial and behaving like she does it can only give county Democrats some small hope that voters will see their candidate as a viable choice, or at lest by coming up with a more reasonable Republican who will run for Mesa County Clerk. So far, and it’s early, only Peters has announced for Clerk (and Colorado Secretary of State too of course).

    How long can Republicans allow this to go on?

  3. If anyone knows what Ms. Peters problem (s) is/are I believe Ann Landman does. If she is hesitant to voice them she only needs to ask a certain party close to her for an opinion. While I would like to see Ms. Peters do the right thing for the people of Mesa County I’m sure she will not even know what that might be. It is clear that her supporters will not agree with Ann’s post and I would not be surprised if her supporters do not share some of Ms. Peters problems, too.

  4. Back to the beginning. What, who, and how much convinced Tina to run for Clerk in the first place? WHY might be the key to it all. Has she ever held office for anything previously? What did she do for a living prior to being the Clerk? There is something fishy going on and needs a good investigative report to find out.

  5. Tina Peters is behaving poorly, which may or may not have anything to do with mental illness.

    There are indeed many illnesses of old age which could account. Progressive Parkinson’s disease, D3 vitamin deficiency, past traumatic brain injury, onset of Alzheimer’s to name a few.

    It’s a very sad situation indeed. She’s definitely being punked by a an evangelical beauty product saleswoman and ilk.

    Mental illness doesn’t cause a large amount criminal behavior though. There’s hard data on that.

    It’s important that the rest of us don’t rely on the save interrogative laziness as Peters has.

    • James, this comment sounds like sarcasm. If you do not understand the sincere seriousness of this article then you need to read it with others and have a discussion.

      Anne may be the first to detail the issue of Tina’s health but she is not the first to notice Tina’s ill health. A good friend observed that Tina’s actions are not healthy and for her own benefit she should step aside. Many of her self inflicted troubles will go away if she truthfully admits her mistakes and steps down.

    • Don’t blame the messenger, Peters is losing it. And needs help. She also needs to stop helping the coupsters destroy our Democracy. What about her actions James? She’s clearly unfit for office. Country over party.

    • Tsk, tsk, James.

      Regardless of the causes of today’s GOP conspiracy cultists’ behavior, we all need to work to limit the damage their actions produce.

      Speak out, register non affiliated, and vote.

Leave a Reply to Tony Stark Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.